An ivory-covered table set for eight in a warm, sunlit neighborhood restaurant dining room, with walnut chairs and understated autumn greenery.

Where to Seat a Holiday Crowd on The Hill

On The Hill, your guest count chooses the restaurant before the menu does. Pavilion, the omakase room behind Sado, seats twelve people, and its largest single table holds four. A few blocks away, Favazza's on the Hill and its banquet facility, the Rose of the Hill, are listed by Explore St. Louis for groups of up to 500. Every other dining room on The Hill has its own limit, from a kitchen table for eight to a 300-seat restaurant. Count your people first, then pick the room.

That matters most between Thanksgiving and New Year's, when one dinner can mean grandparents, cousins in from out of town, and a few kids. The Hill's newer restaurants are small rooms built around a chef. The older family restaurants were built for rehearsal dinners, retirements and parish celebrations, and they still have the back rooms to show for it. Below, the rooms are sorted by how many people they can seat.

Up to eight: the small rooms are open to you

At eight or fewer, every room on The Hill is an option, including the newest ones.

Pizzeria da Gloria, the wood-fired pizzeria between Milo's and St. Ambrose, books reservations for 2 to 8 people. Larger parties are asked to call or email, and the restaurant cannot seat more than 10 in the dining room or 12 on the patio, "including broken up." The patio is not fully covered, and the restaurant says it can't guarantee a move indoors if a patio reservation gets rained on. That's worth knowing before you book an outdoor table for December. If every slot is taken, da Gloria runs a waitlist you can join before you arrive.

Lorenzo's Trattoria has one of the neighborhood's more unusual small rooms. The Kitchen Table seats up to 8 at a single round table just off the kitchen. You can watch the cooks through it while the room stays closed off from the noise. Lorenzo's takes regular reservations through OpenTable or by phone at 314.773.2223.

Sado is the strictest of the small rooms. Pavilion's roughly eighteen-course omakase runs Friday and Saturday at 5:30 and 8:30 p.m. and costs $185 per person, paid when you book. Seats are released on Resy one month before the date, at 10 a.m. For a December Saturday, that means watching the calendar in November.

Nine to twelve: the cutoff where the small rooms drop out

At this size, the newer rooms start turning you away and the private rooms take over.

Sado's answer for any party larger than four at Pavilion is to email [email protected] about a full buyout of the twelve-seat room. At Lorenzo's, the BOARD Room seats up to 12 with a view of the wine racks, and it has the full menu. At Charlie Gitto's on the Hill, the LaSorda Room holds up to 12. It rents in two-hour blocks for a $200 room fee. If the restaurant can't use that room, it seats your group in the main dining areas and takes the fee off the final bill.

For a party above twelve, the chef-driven rooms that opened in the last few years can't seat you together at one table, and the older family restaurants become the realistic choice.

Thirteen to fifty: the rooms the old guard built

This is the usual size for a family holiday dinner, and it is where the older Hill restaurants were designed to do their best work.

Gian-Tony's has a private room for 30, and its other two dining rooms seat 40 and 60. This is the restaurant's second holiday season under new owners. On December 1, 2025, the Catarinicchia family handed it to Joe and Dominic Bergfeld, who kept the entire original staff and former owner and executive chef Tony Catarinicchia's Sicilian recipes. They also plan a backyard patio and interior upgrades. Walk-ins are welcome, but the restaurant recommends reservations. It's open for dinner Wednesday through Sunday and closed Monday and Tuesday.

Guido's Pizzeria & Tapas, run by the Carretero family since 1988, serves Italian classics alongside Spanish tapas. Its private event space is for parties of 25 or more and holds 48 guests. It has a $200 room fee and a $1,700 spending minimum on Friday, Saturday and Sunday evenings. If your party is closer to 25 than 48, a weeknight is the easier way to reach that minimum.

Explore St. Louis lists Bartolino's Osteria for groups of 8 to 45 and Zia's, at the corner of Wilson and Edwards, for groups of 30 to 90.

Fifty to one hundred: the banquet rooms

Charlie Gitto's Garden Room holds up to 100. According to the Hill 2000 business directory, Mama's on the Hill has a banquet facility for up to 100 guests with its own private bar and restrooms. Mama's also bills itself as the "Home of the Toasted Ravioli" and traces the dish to an early-1940s kitchen accident, when a chef named Fritz dropped ravioli into hot oil instead of water. Its own site lists take-and-bake lasagna for gatherings and holidays with 24 hours' notice. If the group is hosting at home instead, that's an option too.

Explore St. Louis lists Guido's for groups up to 100. It also lists the D'Amici Room, connected with Carnivore, for up to 100 in the 1915 Mercantile Building, with high ceilings, large windows and brick detailing.

Past one hundred: whole-building territory

Only a few Hill restaurants can take a crowd this size, and they're among the neighborhood's longest-running names.

A full buyout of Charlie Gitto's on the Hill seats 180. Explore St. Louis lists Anthonino's Taverna, a family-owned restaurant serving Italian and Greek food on The Hill since 2003, for groups of 40 to 150. The same guide lists Rigazzi's, which it calls the oldest restaurant on The Hill, for groups up to 300. Rigazzi's takes private-event inquiries through its website.

Favazza's is the largest. The restaurant at 5201 Southwest Ave seats 300 and handles everything from rehearsal dinners to corporate gatherings. It also caters home parties if the crowd won't fit around your own table. Check its calendar before you plan around it. Favazza's site lists the restaurant as closed on Sundays, Thanksgiving Day, Christmas Eve and Christmas.

When there's no booking at all

Some of The Hill's best-known tables don't take bookings for any party size, and holiday visitors are often surprised by it.

Cunetto House of Pasta has a longstanding policy of not taking reservations. Dinner starts at 4:45 p.m. Wednesday through Sunday, lunch service is suspended, and the restaurant is closed Mondays and Tuesdays. If your group is set on Cunetto's, plan to arrive early and plan for everyone to wait together.

Zia's splits the difference. It holds half its seats for walk-ins, takes reservations Tuesday through Saturday for lunch and Tuesday through Friday for dinner, and takes none on Saturdays after 3 p.m. That makes a Friday dinner the safest way to book Zia's ahead of time. On Saturday night, you take your chances along with everyone else.

Before you call

Holiday hours on The Hill change from year to year. Several of these restaurants close one or two days a week even outside the holidays. Cunetto's and Gian-Tony's both close Monday and Tuesday, and Favazza's closes Sunday. Once you know your headcount, call before you invite anyone, and ask the restaurant to confirm its schedule for the exact date you have in mind. If the gathering falls in early December, the neighborhood's fall and holiday calendar is worth checking too, since Christmas on The Hill and the Marketplace on the Hill night market both bring crowds to the same streets.

Our neighborhood page for The Hill has more about the blocks around these dining rooms.

At Team Bravo, we're always glad to share local tips like these. If you're hosting family this season and want help choosing a dinner spot, or you're thinking about a home closer to these restaurants, reach out to us. We're happy to help.

Experience Seamless Buying & Selling

We'd love to hear from you! Whether you're buying, selling, or just exploring your options, we're here to provide answers, insights, and the support you need. Contact us and start planning your next move.

Follow Us on Instagram